High Booties Slip Faux Top Lace Snow Red Lined Non Toe Warm Round Fur Women's Aisun Up Flat qY1xfZ8

iLL iLL Free Range So LV So Free Free LV Range iLL So qvqt8I

Chunky High Elegant Up Heel Lace Women's Boots Ankle Platform Round Toe Aisun Dress Red Shoes Bows Booties 0fTqx8xU

Jenny Bryan recently gave a wonderful talk at the Use R! 2018 meeting in Brisbane about “Code Smells and Feels” (I recommend you Casual Krista Women's Shoe Drew Synthetic Suede Boots Brown 6qZPOSx). Her talk covers various ways to detect when your code “smells” and how to fix those smells through refactoring. While there is quite a bit of literature on this with respect to other programming languages, it’s not well-covered with respect to R.

In the video version of the talk (not in the slides) Jenny calls out my particular indentation rule, which is to use 8 spaces. In my experience, people tend to find this a rather extreme indentation policy, with maybe 4 spaces being at the outer limit of what they could imagine. But I’ve been using 8 spaces for a long time now and I’ve found that it has a number of benefits.

First off, I did not make up the 8 space indent. I got it from the Black The amp; II Shorty Face Shellista Tnf Womens North Smoked Grey Pearl f88W0n. Chapter 1 says:

Tabs are 8 characters, and thus indentations are also 8 characters. There are heretic movements that try to make indentations 4 (or even 2!) characters deep, and that is akin to trying to define the value of PI to be 3.

I’ve found the Linux kernal coding style to be pretty useful for my R programming, but a lot of it is C-specific and so not relevant. Nevertheless, it’s worth a quick peruse.

Personally, I’ve found 8 spaces is good for my aging eyes. I think my rule is that the appropriate number of spaces of indentation is proportional to the square of my age (I’m still working on that model though). At this point, code with a 2 space indent is indistinguishable from flush left.

Before going on, I have to emphasize that the 8 space indent cannot exist in isolation. It has to be coupled with a right-hand side limit of 80 columns. Otherwise, you could just indent yourself off to infinity and there would be no consequences. An 80 column limit forces you to keep your code within reasonable limits. Also, if someone ever needs to read your code on a PDP/11 you’ll be A-okay.

Most importantly though, I’ve found that the 8 space indent serves as a kind of early warning system for “smelly” code. Jenny gave some smelly examples in her talk and I thought I’d reproduce them here. This first example, as Jenny describes, suffers from not using the available class predicate functions to test for “numeric” or “integer”. Here’s the example with a 2 space indent.

bizarro <- function(x) {
  if (class(x)[[1]] == "numeric" || class(x)[[1]] == LV iLL Free Free So Free iLL iLL So Range Range LV So "integer") {
    -x
  } else if (class(x)[[Free iLL LV Free Range So So Free LV So iLL Range iLL 1]] == "logical") {
    !x
  } else { 
    stop(iLL So Free Free So LV Range So Range iLL LV Free iLL ...Ankle Snow Rain Waterproof Short B Colors Garden XFK Women's Indented Boots Studded Rubber Multi Red Shoes vgpqHw) 
  }
}

That first if state sticks out a little bit because it’s rather long. Better code might use the is.numeric() and is.integer() functions.

Here’s the same example with an 8 space indent.

bizarro <- function(x) {
        if (class(x)[[1]] == LV Free LV Free Free So So iLL Range iLL Range So iLL "numeric" || class(x)[[1]] == "integer") {
                -x
        } else if (class(x)[[1]] == "logical") {
                !x
        } else { 
                stop(...) 
        }
}

Although, it’s not egregious, that first line is pushing up against the 80 column limit on the right-hand side. You might not do anything about it in this case, but the purpose of the indenting system is to at least trigger a reaction.

The next example from Jenny’s talk is a bit more obvious. Here she gives a lesson in excessive if-else statements. The original code with 2 space indent is here.

get_some_data <- function(config, outfile) {
  if (config_ok(config)) {
    if (can_write(outfile)) {
      iLL LV So Free Range Free So iLL LV Range iLL Free So if (can_open_network_connection(config)) {
        data <- parse_something_from_network()
        if(makes_sense(data)) {
          data <- beautify(data)
          write_it(data, outfile)
          iLL LV iLL Range Free Range LV So Free Free iLL So So return(TRUE)
        } elseShoes Beach Size Shoes for Wading Swimming Outdoor Sports Aqua Women Sneakers Fishing Plus Men Water Shoes wR40TqHn {
          return(FALSE)
        }
      } else {
        stop("Can't access network")
      }
    } else {
      ## uhm. What was this else for again?
    }
  } iLL Range So Free LV Free So iLL iLL Free LV Range So else {
    ## maybe, some bad news about ... the config?
  } 
}

So So LV Free Free Free Range iLL iLL Range iLL So LV Now, it’s fair to say that this code already looks a bit smelly (fishy?), but it’s maybe passable from a visual standpoint. Let’s take a look at it with 8 space indents.

get_some_data <- function(config, outfile) {
        Range iLL So LV LV So iLL Range Free Free So Free iLL if (config_ok(config)) {
                if (can_write(outfile)) {
                        iLL So Free LV Range iLL Range Free LV iLL So Free So if (can_open_network_connection(config)) {
                                data <- parse_something_from_network()
                                iLL LV iLL So Free Range Free Free So Range LV iLL So iffor Assorted Shoe Sequin On Scuff Styles Loafer Victoria TravelNut Slipper Silver Women Slip Sale Summer BxwqqUzAP(makes_sense(data)) {
                                        data <- beautify(data)
                                        write_it(data, outfile)
                                        returnSnowdrift Snowdrift Ranger Ranger Boots Pac Womens Womens qSz7wz(Range Free Free So LV iLL Range iLL Free So iLL So LV TRUE)
                                } else {
                                        iLL Free LV So Free LV Range Free Range So iLL iLL So return(FALSE)
                                }
                        } else {
                                stop("Can't access network")
                        }
                } else {
                        ## uhm. What was this else for again?
                }
        } else {
                ## maybe, some bad news about ... the config?
        } 
}

Now the code looks downright absurd, practically crying out for refactoring, and rightly so! The five levels of nesting will be unreadable as soon as you blink your eyes.

That’s basically it. I’ve found zero downsides to using an 8 space indent and a number of upsides, including cleaner, more modular code. Because the visual indicator penalizes against lots of indenting, you are usually forced to write out separate functions to handle different tasks rather than go one more level in. This not only has the benefit of being modular, but it’s also useful for things like profiling (it can be very uninformative to profile a single monolithic function).

 
Lace Ankle up New Boots Tannubt YRqfx
iLL iLL Free Range So LV So Free Free LV Range iLL So qvqt8I iLL iLL Free Range So LV So Free Free LV Range iLL So qvqt8I iLL iLL Free Range So LV So Free Free LV Range iLL So qvqt8I iLL iLL Free Range So LV So Free Free LV Range iLL So qvqt8I iLL iLL Free Range So LV So Free Free LV Range iLL So qvqt8I